Mappy Kwolistmukah
Since I’m not a “real” scientist (as Psychology is really just a bunch of guess work that does not apply to all situations), I prefer to write about things on this website that you can not disprove; my opinions. So sit down and enjoy my wild rantings about why I’m right and everyone else is wrong.
It’s that time of year again. The weather is growing steadily worse and more uncomfortable, the malls are crammed to and beyond capacity, and the credit card companies are licking their chops at the thought of all of the interest that will soon be compiling on numerous accounts. That’s right, it’s the Holidays/ Christmas/ Solstice/ Chanukah/ Kwanza/ Festivus/ insert your other holiday here. Recently, Mr. Dan Grible and I along with a few others (whose names I don’t recall since I’m horrible with names and was only given them once) had a very brief conversation about the phrase “Merry Christmas”. The question posed was, “What do you think about ‘Merry Christmas?’” If my recollection is correct, the answer from all of us was something along the lines of “I don’t care”. That’s right, I don’t care and I don’t understand why most people seem so opinionated on the “Merry Christmas” vs. “Happy Holidays” debate.
I’ve worked retail and I’ve heard horror stories about these kinds of things. “Here’s your change, Happy Holidays!” “IT’S MERRY CHRISTMAS!!!” Really? Why get so worked up about two words? The other day I was wished a Merry Christmas by a man at White Castle. I simply smiled and returned the sentiment. It doesn’t matter what you say, it’s all for the same purpose. It’s a wish of happiness (usually) attached to a certain day. And just because you’re on the “Happy Holidays” team, don’t think you’re safe from guilt.
I recently found a group on facebook about this debate. I didn’t plan on joining but there was one post that caught my eye. In summary it said, “Jesus wasn’t born this time of year anyway, he wouldn’t care what you say, just be nice to each other.” This woman was attacked by three or four people. I joined the group and defended the woman despite the fact that we share differing points of view on religion.
So here’s what it all amounts to. If you want to be wished a Merry Christmas, wear some kind of symbol to let me know that. Same goes for Chanukah. If you want “Happy Holidays”, don’t show any kind of symbol and that’s what you’re going to get. If you want Kwanza, well, you’re out of luck because I’m not sure what that’s all about and don’t know the symbols.
So, I’m done, my food just arrived and I’m too lazy to proofread. So go, reply and tear apart my poor grammar/ sentence structure, post your horror stories, or tell me why I’m wrong (which I’m not). Also, read the previous post about the planning meeting and attend. Although I know that the four to five people that will read this will also probably be there.
EDIT: First mistake found. Sorry Dan.
Categories Uncategorized
Leave a Reply
By submitting a comment here you grant Students for Freethought a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Inappropriate or irrelevant comments will be removed at an admin's discretion.











4 Comments to Mappy Kwolistmukah
by NSMauger
On December 16, 2009 at 8:54 pm
I couldn’t agree with you more. I tend to say “Happy Holidays” too, but I’m almost never bothered by people who choose to say “Merry Christmas” instead. I think there are far more important issues facing the humanist/secular movement right now, and quibbling over the phrasing of one’s holiday greeting only serves to distract from them.
by Ashley Paramore
On December 17, 2009 at 10:12 am
Ha – it’s funny you write about this because I’m about to edit a youtube video on it. xD
But all-in-all, I think we’re in agreement here…
by Kevin Gessler
On December 17, 2009 at 5:43 pm
I agree with almost everything, but there’s a point that I’d like to make. I say Happy Holidays, not because I’d be offended by someone wishing me a Merry Christmas (or Happy Chanuka), I say it to remind people that not everyone believes as they do.
The problem then is that at points you can seem confrontational if you use Happy Holidays in some ways. What I do is say Happy Holidays if I say a seasonal phrase first, and if second, I say whatever they said back. Unless I feel that they are of the opinion that I’m Christian, in which case I may still say Happy Holidays, just to give them a subtle reminder that they can’t make assumptions about what I believe. That would be one of the few motivations for me to say Happy Holidays to someone I know. They are after all trying to wish me well.
For the same reason I don’t yell at people that say “God bless you,” to me when I sneeze. They are merely wishing me well, and don’t deserve insults or slights in return.
by kkeckley
On December 17, 2009 at 10:09 pm
I agree completely Kevin. In my experience the “Merry Christmas only” crowd seems to be the most confrontational. I just didn’t want to appear to be playing favorites =)